Back in early 2021, I published an article expressing a controversial opinion: Breath of the Wild had effectively ruined the traditional Zelda experience for me. As my introduction to the series, its open-ended nature made the classic, structured titles feel inaccessible and dated. However, spending time with the new Ocarina of Time remake on the Nintendo Switch 2 has completely shifted my perspective, leading me to offer a formal apology to Link.
Rediscovering the Magic of Dungeons
While my initial foray into Ocarina of Time felt slow due to its tutorial-heavy opening, the experience transformed once the adventure truly kicked off. It didn't take long to realize why long-time fans have been vocal about the absence of traditional dungeons in the newer titles. Upon reaching adulthood in the game, the brilliance of Nintendo's level design became undeniable.
The Forest, Fire, and Water Temples serve as masterclasses in puzzle design. Each dungeon provides a unique tool that is essential for overcoming obstacles, encouraging players to utilize their entire inventory creatively. Comparing them to the more repetitive Divine Beast dungeons of the modern era, the classic format feels far more cohesive and rewarding.
The Best of Both Worlds
Despite my newfound appreciation for the structured approach of Ocarina of Time, my admiration for the freedom of Breath of the Wild remains intact. The modern titles excel in allowing players to solve problems using a variety of inventive methods—an area where the more linear design of the 1998 classic is naturally more restricted.
Ultimately, I believe the future of the franchise lies in synthesis. As I noted in my experience:
«I think both classic and modern Zelda have huge strengths, and opting for one over the other in any future Zelda games would be disappointing. I hope the development team at Nintendo mashes the two design philosophies together.»
A Path Forward
The gaming industry has already seen successful examples of this hybrid approach. Much like the 'Legacy Dungeons' found in Elden Ring, which blend expansive exploration with tightly crafted interior spaces, the next mainline Zelda title would benefit from marrying these two distinct design pillars. While we wait to see what Nintendo does next, I plan to explore more of the classic catalog, perhaps starting with Majora's Mask if a remake ever arrives.
